Skip to content
All posts

Shopify vs Big Cartel vs GoDaddy: costs, limits and who each fits

The title Shopify vs Big Cartel vs GoDaddy: costs and limits beside three glass cards of rising height holding a few, then many, then endless soft product photos, with a price tag and a coin stack in front.

By Hanz Sofyan Published 5 min read

Summarize with AI

Shopify vs Big Cartel vs GoDaddy depends on the shop, because each suits a different one. Big Cartel holds 5, 50 or 500 products a plan and takes no cut of a sale itself. Shopify Basic costs $29 a month paid yearly and sets no product cap. GoDaddy sells a website builder with a store plan. Count your products first: that settles Big Cartel against Shopify.

Your sixth print is ready, and your plan lists five. Or your domain sits at GoDaddy, and you wonder if it follows you to a new store. On November 19, 2026, we read Shopify's and Big Cartel's own pages and worked out one month on each.

Which one fits your shop?

Pick by how many products you sell and how long you mean to keep growing, because Big Cartel's plans stop at 500 and Shopify Basic does not.

Big Cartel says it is built for creators and artists, and Shopify is a hosted store you rent by the month.

If youLook atWhy
Sell five products or fewer and want no monthly billBig Cartel GoldGold is free and lists 5 products, and Big Cartel adds no fee of its own to a sale
Sell up to 50 productsBig Cartel Platinum$15 a month, or $12 paid yearly, with support for a custom domain
Sell up to 500 and want abandoned carts recoveredBig Cartel DiamondAbandoned cart recovery and scheduled drops start there
Expect the catalog to pass 500ShopifyBasic sells unlimited products
Keep your domain and site at GoDaddy and want the store on the same accountGoDaddyGoDaddy sells a domain, a website builder and a store plan together
Already own your domain at GoDaddyShopifyShopify connects a name you registered at GoDaddy automatically, so you keep it
Sell a product in many combinations, such as size, color and fitShopifyA product takes up to 2,048 variants, against Big Cartel's 150

From Big Cartel's and Shopify's own pages and GoDaddy's blog, read November 19, 2026.

Say you sell one paperback and wonder whether a monthly plan is worth it for a single product. A free plan that lists five products covers that, and the question returns when the sixth title is ready. Selling prints? How to sell art online covers the wider route, and Etsy vs Shopify fees covers a marketplace.

Weighing eBay, Magento or Wix too? eBay vs Shopify, Shopify vs Magento vs BigCommerce and Shopify vs Wix take each in turn.

What does each plan cost a month?

Big Cartel's paid plans cost $15 and $30 a month, and Shopify Basic costs $39, before the yearly discount.

PlanPaid yearlyPaid monthlyTo start
Shopify Basic$29 a month$39 a monthThree days free, then $1 a month for three months
Big Cartel Gold$0$0No card needed, 5 products
Big Cartel Platinum$12 a month ($144 a year)$15 a month7-day free trial, card needed
Big Cartel Diamond$24 a month ($288 a year)$30 a monthNone listed
GoDaddy store planSee GoDaddy's plan pageSee GoDaddy's plan pageSee GoDaddy's plan page

Big Cartel's pricing page, read November 19, 2026; Shopify's US pricing page, archived November 19, 2026.

Big Cartel's pricing page in the monthly view: the Platinum card reads $0 to start with a 7 days free trial, then $15 a month, and the Diamond card reads $30 a month, each above its list of features, with a line below linking to the free Gold Plan.
Big Cartel's own pricing page, monthly view, read November 19, 2026.

Big Cartel says paying yearly saves 20%. Platinum's trial needs a card on file, and Gold does not. GoDaddy lists its store plan's price on its own plan page, so check it there before you decide. Shopify pricing covers Grow, Advanced and Plus.

What does each take from a sale?

Big Cartel adds no fee of its own to a sale, and Shopify Basic adds none on Shopify Payments, so the card rate sets the month.

Big Cartel prints 0% transaction fees on all plans. It does not process payments itself, so Stripe and PayPal do, and Stripe starts at 2.9% + 30¢ a card. Shopify Basic charges 2.9% + 30¢ on a standard US card online through Shopify Payments.

A made-up monthShopify Basic, paid yearlyBig Cartel Platinum, paid monthlyBig Cartel Gold
Plan$29.00$15.00$0.00
Card fees, 100 orders of $50$175.00$175.00$175.00
The month$204.00$190.00$175.00, five products

A made-up shop with 100 online orders of $50, every shopper on a standard US card, worked out from the pricing pages, read November 19, 2026. It leaves out shipping, tax, the domain and a paid theme. Big Cartel's card rate is Stripe's starting rate.

Paid yearly, Big Cartel Platinum comes to $187.00 and Diamond to $199.00. If 20 of those shoppers pay with a business or American Express card, Shopify Basic's 3.5% + 30¢ rate adds $6.00. Through another payment provider, Shopify Basic adds 2% of each sale, or $100.00 on $5,000. Shopify does not return the card fee on a refund.

How many products can each hold?

Big Cartel lists 5 products on Gold, 50 on Platinum and 500 on Diamond, and Shopify Basic sells unlimited products.

A product you hide still counts toward the limit. Go back to the free plan with more than five products, and the shop goes into maintenance mode until you pick five to keep. Images follow the plan too, with one per product on Gold, five on Platinum and 25 on Diamond.

Three sections of Big Cartel's plan guide, cut at the dashed lines: the free Gold plan sells up to five products, the Platinum plan at $15.00 a month or $144 a year lists up to 50 products with 5 images each, and the Diamond plan at $30.00 a month or $288 a year lists up to 500 products with 25 images each.
Big Cartel's plan guide (its page is dated February 25, 2025), read November 19, 2026. The dashed lines mark where the long page was cut.

A Big Cartel product takes up to 3 options and 150 variants, and a Shopify product takes up to 3 options and 2,048. The Shopify variants guide shows how they work.

On Big Cartel, abandoned cart recovery, scheduled drops and password-protected products start on Diamond. Shopify Basic includes abandoned checkout recovery and discount codes.

Can you move later, and keep your GoDaddy domain?

Yes: a domain at GoDaddy connects to Shopify automatically, and a GoDaddy store's products move by spreadsheet.

Your domain can stay at GoDaddy. In your Shopify admin, open Settings > Domains, click "Connect existing" (the button for a name you already own), type the name in the Domain box and click Next, then click "Connect automatically" and sign in to GoDaddy. If your email is hosted at GoDaddy, keep your existing mail settings when you update the DNS settings (the settings that tell the internet where your domain points).

The Domains page of a Shopify admin with the buttons Connect existing, Transfer domain and Buy new domain at the top right, a card titled Change to a new myshopify.com domain, and a table whose one row is the store's myshopify.com address, tagged Primary and marked Connected.
Shopify's Domains page, under Settings: "Connect existing" is the button for a domain you already own, at GoDaddy or elsewhere.

Shopify's free Store Migration app lists neither GoDaddy nor Big Cartel, and Shopify's migration index lists a guide for GoDaddy and none for Big Cartel. The GoDaddy guide exports your products from the Commerce > Products page of GoDaddy's dashboard, fixes the columns, and imports them under Products > Import. The export carries one image per product, so add the rest after, and reviews stay in Yotpo, the review tool GoDaddy stores use.

Big Cartel imports products from Shopify and keeps them Hidden until you publish. Going the other way, Shopify's import takes a file in Shopify's own spreadsheet format. Migrating to Shopify covers the checklist, and Shopify URL redirects covers the old addresses. Closing a Big Cartel shop leaves your order history in Stripe and PayPal.

FAQ

Questions, answered

  • 14-day free trial

    Explore Sledge on your store before you decide to commit.

  • No credit card required

    Start improving your store with no upfront commitment.

  • Setup in minutes

    Get Sledge running without a lengthy setup process.

  • Built to grow sales

    Turn shopper behavior into actions that help you sell more.

Is Big Cartel cheaper than Shopify?

Its paid plans cost less a month. Big Cartel Platinum is $15 a month, or $12 paid yearly, and Diamond is $30, or $24 paid yearly. Shopify Basic is $39 a month, or $29 paid yearly. The plans hold different amounts: Platinum lists up to 50 products, and Basic sets no cap.

How many products can you sell on Big Cartel?

Big Cartel's free Gold plan lists 5 products, Platinum up to 50 and Diamond up to 500. A product set to Hidden still counts toward the limit. Shopify Basic sells unlimited products, so the cap only matters if your catalog may pass 500.

Does Big Cartel or GoDaddy charge transaction fees?

Big Cartel prints 0% transaction fees on all plans, so you pay only the card processor, which starts at 2.9% + 30¢ through Stripe. GoDaddy lists its card rate on its payments page. Shopify Basic adds no fee on Shopify Payments and 2% on another provider.

Is Shopify or GoDaddy better for a small business?

It depends on the shop. GoDaddy fits you if your domain and site already live there and you want a store beside them. Shopify fits you if you expect the catalog to grow, since Basic sets no product cap, or you want a card reader at a counter.

Can you use a GoDaddy domain with Shopify?

Yes. In your Shopify admin, open Settings > Domains, click Connect existing, enter the name and click Next, then click Connect automatically and sign in to GoDaddy. If your email is hosted at GoDaddy, keep your existing mail settings when you update the DNS settings.

Can you move from Big Cartel or GoDaddy to Shopify?

Yes, by spreadsheet. Shopify's free Store Migration app lists neither platform, but its Help Center has a GoDaddy guide that exports your products and imports them under Products > Import. For Big Cartel, Shopify's migration index lists no guide, so you build the file in Shopify's format. Our migration guide covers the redirects.

Moving to Shopify? Make a bigger catalog easy to browse.

Sledge doesn't run on Big Cartel or GoDaddy, and it doesn't change what either charges. On Shopify, it adds search, filters and offers to your store. Try it free for 14 days, then plans start at $29.99 a month with no cut of your sales. On a paid plan, Growth Intelligence lists fixes for your store and sums them as one dollar figure, "Est. potential".